Aaron Rodgers is ranked 31st among NFL quarterbacks by analyst Jon Ledyard, ahead of only one player.
What happened?
Ledyard explained his decision, stating Rodgers can still produce occasional flashes, but no longer provides consistently reliable quarterback play.
He pointed to increased mistakes and declining mobility as reasons for the low ranking.
Why it matters for Aaron Rodgers
The ranking comes after Rodgers led the Pittsburgh Steelers to an AFC North title and a 10-7 finish in 2025.
Despite this, Ledyard and other analysts, including ESPN's Seth Walder, have questioned Rodgers' ability to handle pressure consistently.
What comes next?
The Steelers re-signed Rodgers to a one-year, $22.5 million contract, but also drafted rookie Drew Allar in the third round to develop for the future.
Walder suggested the team should have targeted a younger quarterback, such as Malik Willis or Kyler Murray, instead of relying on Rodgers.
The Steelers' decision to keep Rodgers is seen as a move for immediate stability, but the team's long-term plans remain uncertain.
Rodgers' ability to perform at a high level will be closely watched, especially given his age and recent decline in form.
The 2026 season will be a crucial test for Rodgers and the Steelers, as they look to build on their success from last year.
Ledyard's ranking has sparked debate among fans and analysts, with some defending Rodgers' abilities and others agreeing with the assessment.
The NFL Daily with Gregg Rosenthal podcast, where Ledyard made his comments, has been widely discussed on social media.
Rodgers' contract and the Steelers' offseason moves have been subject to scrutiny, with many wondering if the team made the right decisions.
As the new season approaches, all eyes will be on Rodgers and the Steelers to see how they perform.
The team's success will depend on Rodgers' ability to lead and perform at a high level, despite his advanced age.